Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Let's ditch the 49th

I sometimes get a little miffed at the casual use of "the 49th parallel" to denote the Canada/US border.

It's a handy reference because you have that unbroken line from Lake of the Woods west to BC staring you in the face whenever you look at a map, but the 49th is an essentially meaningless line east of there. I'll demonstrate.

All of the Great Lakes, the entire Windsor-Quebec corridor, all of New Brunswick, PEI, and Nova Scotia, and a majority of the island of Newfoundland are actually south of the 49th. Even a lot of logging and mining towns in 'north' Ontario and Quebec come in south of the line. By my rough calculations, it adds up to almost 20 million people, which means almost 2/3 of Canadians live below the magic line that supposedly delinates us from the dread them.

As far as I can figure it, the most substantial settlements north of 49 in Eastern Canada are Sept-Iles and baie-Comeau, which, at about 25,000 each, are hardly comparable to a Winnipeg or an Edmonton. Saguenay, Timmins, Corner Brook, and others come close, but they all end up at 48.whatever north.

I know this is ignoring how Canadian identity is so often tied up with the frozen north and such (even though most of us live as far south as our part of the country will permit us to), but it's still a point I wanted to make. I want to make it bad enough that I spent 20 minutes in Google Earth and 5 minutes in MS Paint! That is a large investment of time, these days.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Why not call it "The Freedom Squiggle?"
-AM

WJM said...

I sometimes get a little miffed at the casual use of "the 49th parallel" to denote the Canada/US border.

Almost like using "mainland" to distinguish the 10th province from the rest of Canada, even when that province is mostly mainland itself...

Michael Collins said...

Did someone do that recently, WJM?

I believe a letter-writting campaign is in order, Mr. AM.

WJM said...

Did someone do that recently, WJM?

Constantly.

Jane said...

That is quite the time investment.

I've never really thought of it to tell you the truth. Never really heard it much either. All in all good to know to avoid make rash generalizations though.

Jen said...

Does the line include the great state of Alaska? As a lowly American reader, I don't know. I never really had geography class.

Barfinkle Turdsmoggle said...

NEW POSTS ABOUT CANADA ARE SORELY PINED FOR. Or is that "NEW POSTS ABOUT CANADA FOR WHICH ARE SORELY PINED?"

Gabriel Hurley said...

You had commented on my post about St. John being the happiest city in Canada. I have now updated the population data and incorporated the original happiness data into my graph. The result can be seen here: http://dailyobserver.blogspot.com/2009/07/much-more-scientific-are-you-happy-now.html